Open Hearth Lodge is a family-owned, rustic hotel set on a 6.5-acre site in Sister Bay, Wisconsin. It offers a casual and cozy atmosphere with rooms and suites designed for comfort, including accommodations that are pet-friendly. The property features practical amenities such as free Wi-Fi, free breakfast, and free parking, making it a convenient choice for a range of travelers.
Guests can enjoy a heated indoor swimming pool, a hot tub, and a fitness center on site, along with an accessible smoke-free environment. The lodge’s service has been highlighted in reviews for its attentive and friendly staff, often praised as a standout feature compared to larger hotel chains. Some visitors particularly appreciate the welcoming dog-friendly facilities, including secure outdoor areas and in-room pet amenities.
Its location is convenient for visitors planning to explore nearby attractions, including Peninsula State Park, Eagle Bluff Lighthouse, and Newport State Park, all known for outdoor recreation and scenic beauty. The lodge is less than two miles from the American Folklore Theatre and the center of Sister Bay, providing easy access to local dining and entertainment options.
Reviewers frequently note the lodge’s inviting ambiance, with features like fire pits and a casual lounge space adding to the overall experience. While some guests mention additional conveniences such as laundry facilities and affordability of snacks and beverages, the property’s mid-afternoon check-in and late morning check-out times accommodate flexible travel plans. Suitable for families, pet owners, and those seeking a relaxed, rustic setting, Open Hearth Lodge offers a straightforward and comfortable stay in Door County.
Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.