GoHotelly
2-star hotel Check-in 15:30 · Check-out 11:00

Open Hearth Lodge

Cozy rooms, free breakfast, and heated indoor pool at Open Hearth Lodge in Sister Bay, WI. Close to Peninsula State Park and Eagle Bluff Lighthouse.

2669 S Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234, United States View on map
9.6/10
Exceptional Based on 672 recent guest reviews
Free Wi-Fi Free breakfast Free parking Accessible Indoor pool
What recent guests emphasize

Comfort, Hospitality, and Rustic Charm

Recent visitors highlight the lodge’s welcoming atmosphere and attentive service, combined with cozy accommodations and useful amenities in a scenic, dog-friendly setting.

Guests often praise

  • Warm, friendly, and accommodating staff praised for exceptional hospitality.
  • Clean, spacious rooms with appealing rustic decor and thoughtful amenities including fireplaces and pet-friendly features.
  • Complimentary breakfast and well-maintained indoor pool and hot tub facilities.
  • Inviting outdoor spaces with fire pits and convenient snack and beverage options.
  • Location close to local attractions and offering easy access to outdoor activities.

Worth knowing

  • The pet-friendly rooms are popular and tend to book quickly; early reservation is recommended for guests traveling with dogs.
  • There is no airport shuttle available, so transportation arrangements should be planned in advance.
  • While parking is free, the lodge is on a rustic site that emphasizes a casual, down-to-earth experience rather than luxury.
  • Guest experiences reflect a cozy lodge rather than a corporate hotel atmosphere; ideal for travelers seeking authenticity.

Best for

  • Travelers looking for a friendly, welcoming atmosphere with personalized service.
  • Pet owners who want dog-friendly accommodations and secure outdoor spaces for pets.
  • Visitors interested in a rustic, cozy lodge experience near outdoor parks and local attractions.
  • Families and groups seeking comfortable rooms, complimentary breakfast, and recreational amenities like a heated pool and hot tub.
Compare booking partners

Open this hotel on the platform you trust.

GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.

Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

About this property

Welcome to Open Hearth Lodge

Open Hearth Lodge is a family-owned, rustic hotel set on a 6.5-acre site in Sister Bay, Wisconsin. It offers a casual and cozy atmosphere with rooms and suites designed for comfort, including accommodations that are pet-friendly. The property features practical amenities such as free Wi-Fi, free breakfast, and free parking, making it a convenient choice for a range of travelers.

Guests can enjoy a heated indoor swimming pool, a hot tub, and a fitness center on site, along with an accessible smoke-free environment. The lodge’s service has been highlighted in reviews for its attentive and friendly staff, often praised as a standout feature compared to larger hotel chains. Some visitors particularly appreciate the welcoming dog-friendly facilities, including secure outdoor areas and in-room pet amenities.

Its location is convenient for visitors planning to explore nearby attractions, including Peninsula State Park, Eagle Bluff Lighthouse, and Newport State Park, all known for outdoor recreation and scenic beauty. The lodge is less than two miles from the American Folklore Theatre and the center of Sister Bay, providing easy access to local dining and entertainment options.

Reviewers frequently note the lodge’s inviting ambiance, with features like fire pits and a casual lounge space adding to the overall experience. While some guests mention additional conveniences such as laundry facilities and affordability of snacks and beverages, the property’s mid-afternoon check-in and late morning check-out times accommodate flexible travel plans. Suitable for families, pet owners, and those seeking a relaxed, rustic setting, Open Hearth Lodge offers a straightforward and comfortable stay in Door County.

Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.
Facilities & essentials

What's on-site and what you should know before you arrive

The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.

Most popular facilities

Free Wi-Fi
Free breakfast
Free parking
Accessible
Indoor pool
Air-conditioned
Pet-friendly
Kid-friendly
Hot tub
Fitness center
Golf course
Smoke-free

Not available at this property

Airport shuttle
Verified guest reviews

What recent guests are actually saying

Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.

EE
Emily Erickson Apr 19, 2026
10

This was the perfect place for a girls weekend. I picked this place due to the amenities and when we arrived, we were surprised with more! Snacks and libations in the lobby for purchase, fire pits galore, live singing entertainment, etc. we got the evergreen suite and it was perfect for us. The bedrooms and bathrooms (2 each) were clean, spacious, and beautiful. We will definitely be returning. 3 minutes away from a delicious Thai/sushi restaurant hidden away.

MB
Michael Bailey Mar 24, 2026
10

The hotel was nice and clean. The free breakfast was also a great bonus. With all that said, nothing tops the staff at the hotel. I spend over 100 nights a year in Marriott hotels and I can say that I have never be shown the hospitality that was shown at the Open Hearth Lodge!

MB
Maggie Benson Mar 21, 2026
10

This lodge was so much better than expected. Inviting, warm, accommodating, clean, and picturesque. Room was ready early (blessing in a snowstorm) close to everything and had a free shuttle to local events. Clean room, ample towels, pool, hot tub, games, puzzles, and books to use. Laundry on site. Food, wine, beer for purchase with glasses to use! (VERY AFFORDABLE). Adorable fire pits and seating outside. Dog friendly with their own in room amenities. Can stream from all the popular services in room and enjoy a private fireplace. Open Hearth was a welcome oasis from the blizzard and had everything we needed and more.

JW
John Wentworth Mar 13, 2026
10

What a nice hotel. Drove past it for 20+ years and never thought twice. Now ... I love this hotel. I will be back. They are dog very friendly. The dog rooms are perfect and spotless. A free breakfast comes with the stay. There is a huge area to walk the puppies and a private fenced in dog potty area. Very secure. The doggie side of the hotel sells out ... alot. Make your reservation early. This place is worth the try. I think you will like it. The hotel is very quiet and the owners are very attentive to their guest. One last note... "I loved this"... fireplaces in the front and back of the hotel were on at night and morning. Visiting with other guest or just being quiet was wonderful. This is a hotel done right. "SO", in conclusion, please don't go there because then I won't be able to get a room... :) !

JE
Jamie Ennis Mar 03, 2026
10

I just stayed the weekend there. This would be my third time staying here, but this time I brought my dog. 1000/10 would highly recommend. We felt so at home with our dog, our dog even felt at home. This place is welcoming, safe, relaxing, dog-friendly and comfortable. Well, located!

GW
Gabe Worden Jan 19, 2026
10

Rarely am I ever this confident to give a 5-star review. It was our 2nd time staying there this weekend. To me, this is an ideal place of lodging. It’s not a fake, sterile, soulless, white and grey corporate hotel. It is pretty much the opposite. Incredible breakfast room. Fire pits outside. Beer/drink/snack selection with Venmo, housekeeping tips also possible with Venmo. Great location. To me, this is exactly what a hotel should be. Thank you guys so much for running such an authentic lodge.

AU
Anonymous user Jan 06, 2026
10

My husband and I are here for our anniversary, we wanted a jetted tub room and this was the only one in the areas available. I’m so glad we chose this one ! We walked in and were greeted immediately by the front desk guy . He was so great . Super friendly and helpful . They are so accommodating. You can really tell they care about the guests and that alone goes a long way . Expensive hotels are overrated these days and nothing beats the service . We will stay again nexts year !

TR
Terry Ringman Dec 28, 2025
10

I've stayed here several times over the years. The amenities are awesome! Beautiful indoor pool and hot tub. They also have a nice exercise room. Can't forget the awesome continental breakfast that they offer! The place is very clean and the staff is friendly and pleasant! I would highly recommend staying here!

Location & neighborhood

Where you'll find Open Hearth Lodge

Sister Bay, Wisconsin, USA

Set on a 6.5-acre site, this family-owned, rustic lodge is a mile from the American Folklore Theatre and 1.3 miles from Sister Bay.

  • Delta County Airport 3 hr 12 Car
Things to do nearby

Worth the walk or a quick ride

Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Wisconsin. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.

Peninsula State Park 5,576 reviews

Peninsula State Park

9462 Shore Rd, Fish Creek, WI 54212, United States

4.8 · State Park
Newport State Park 1,210 reviews

Newport State Park

475 County Rd NP, Ellison Bay, WI 54210, United States

4.8 · State Park
Eagle Bluff Light Station 973 reviews

Eagle Bluff Light Station

10249 Shore Rd, Fish Creek, WI 54212, United States

4.6 · Museum
People also viewed

Similar Hotels in Wisconsin

Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.

302 S Market St, San Jose, CA 95113, United States

The Westin San Jose

Stay at The Westin San Jose with cozy rooms, a restaurant, and meeting space. Located near top sites like Winchester Mystery House...

4.1 (1,287) View
5034 N Desert Blvd, El Paso, TX 79912, United States

Comfort Suites El Paso West

Comfort Suites El Paso West offers free breakfast, indoor pool, and parking. Located in El Paso with easy access to Franklin Mount...

4.3 (523) View
8110 West Fwy, White Settlement, TX 76108, United States

West Worth Inn & Suites

Stay at West Worth Inn & Suites in White Settlement, TX. Enjoy simple rooms, free WiFi & parking, near SeaQuest Fort Worth & majo...

3.4 (271) View
20 International Pl, Tewksbury, MA 01876, United States

Residences at International Place

Stay at Residences at International Place in Tewksbury, MA. Enjoy free WiFi, parking, outdoor pool, and easy access to local attr...

3.7 (55) View
924 Main St, Bennington, VT 05201, United States

Autumn Inn

Autumn Inn offers straightforward rooms with free WiFi, parking, and petfriendly access. Located 1 mile from Downtown Bennington...

3.5 (205) View
1901 Killebrew Dr, Bloomington, MN 55425, United States

Wyndham Bloomington - Mall of America

Stay at Wyndham Bloomington Mall of America with indoor pool, free airport & Mall shuttle. Close to Mall of America, Nickelodeon...

3.5 (1,613) View
Share your stay

Stayed at Open Hearth Lodge? Help the next traveler decide.

Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.

Your email is only used to verify the review — it won't be shown publicly.